約翰·恩特維斯托(John Entwistle)——歐美有史以來十大最佳貝司手

約翰恩特維斯托(John Entwistle)——歐美有史以來十大最佳貝司手在《歐美有史以來十大最佳貝司手》中排名第2名。約翰阿萊克恩特威斯爾，英國歌手、詞曲作家、作曲家、音樂家、電影和音樂制作人，他是世界衛生組織（Who）搖滾樂隊的主要貝斯手 ...

約翰恩特維斯托歐美有史以來十大最佳貝司手在歐美有史以來十大最佳貝司手中排名第2名。

約翰·阿萊克·恩特威斯爾，英國歌手、詞曲作家、作曲家、音樂家、電影和音樂制作人，他是世界衛生組織（Who）搖滾樂隊的主要貝斯手

·······································································

John Alec Entwistle, was an English singer, songwriter, composer, musician, film and music producer. He is mostly known as the lead bassist for the rock band The Who.

·······································································

我們精選了部分網友觀點：

···································································

如果伯頓還活著的話，他就不會排在第一位了。他之所以受到如此多的關注，僅僅是因為他不幸地去世了。恩特威斯爾比伯頓強得多。恩特威斯爾在伯頓之前演奏低音就像一個主樂器，而且比伯頓強得多。如果伯頓和恩特威斯爾在同樣的情況下死去，就沒有人敢叫伯頓了上級。但恩特威斯爾也去世了。-德雷托普滕斯

Come on all you kids who vote on these lists... Look for John Entwistle on YouTube. See the magic he does. There's even a video taken from a cam fixed on the neck of his guitar just to show people what's going on. The man does things with his fingers that, well, are not supposed to be possible. Love you John, rest in peace.

···································································

給任何一個貝司手打分通常是一件非常困難的事情，但在這種情況下，這是相當容易的。同時被《滾石》雜志評為世界上最好的貝司手，并被評為“千年貝司手”，我無法理解另一個貝司手是如何被視為更好的。這根本是不可能的。真正令人驚奇的是他能演奏最令人驚嘆的獨奏曲似乎不費吹灰之力。沒有一個貝司手可以復制他，更不用說想出他想出的獨奏了。說到對樂器的純粹貢獻，約翰也排名第一。他自學如何演奏一種樂器（當時相對較新），比今天任何人都彈得好

Entwisle is a god, and that's as plain as that. So many good bass players, still, in what he did, he has shown mastery and virtuosity beyond understanding. That guy never needed to do antics on the stage. Calm and composed at all times, he lets his fingers talk for him. God knows how many times he had to pick up the whole rhythm section in show because Keith Moon was busy doing something else than playing.

Not present on this list, but should be: Paul McCartney, a truly under-rated bass

···································································

! 約翰·恩特威斯爾怎么會排在第四位呢？這是我們現在談論的最偉大的搖滾貝司手之一。Geddy Lee排名第一，我可以排在后面。當你認為Lee唱主唱，彈奏鍵盤，而且仍然可以說是搖滾音樂中最好的貝司手，他顯然應該得到榜首，但蓋迪·李一直把約翰·恩特威斯爾視為他的主要靈感來源，你肯定可以在蓋迪最喜歡的即興小品中聽到約翰的影響。蓋迪從約翰那里學到了很多東西，并通過運用他從另一個靈感中學習到的工具，使之更為突出，克里斯·斯奎爾。蓋迪開始用瑞肯巴克低音和圓繞弦來模仿鄉紳的聲音。早期的Who音樂大多淹沒了恩特威斯爾令人敬畏的低音即興演奏，因為他用的是平弦樂器，而他那快速的三胞胎常常因為咕噥的咆哮聲而消失，而不是一個清脆的聲音讓那些即興重復。很多…更多

! How in the hell is John Entwistle 4th on any list? This is one of the greatest rock bassists of all time we are talking about here.

Geddy Lee is ranked #1 and I can get behind that. When you concider that Lee sings lead vocals, plays keyboards and is still arguably the best bassists in rock music, he clearly deserves the top spot, but Geddy Lee has always sighted John Entwistle as his main inspiration and you can certainly hear John's influence in many of Geddy's favorite riffs.

···································································

這個人影響了這一頁的大多數人。他從白手起家的小人物那里得到啟發，是搖滾史上第一個寫低音獨奏的貝司手。他也用三個手指演奏。比利·希恩、吉澤·巴特勒、維克多·伍頓、克里斯·諾沃塞利奇，如果不是他，很多其他貝司手也不會把自己的標準定得這么高。我要說的是，如果這些貝司手中的任何一個在約翰之前成名，實際上每個人都會慢得像地下巖石一樣慢。他現在是，而且永遠都是世界上最偉大的貝司手，或者吉他雜志稱他為“世界上最偉大的貝司手”千年”

First of all, just because Rolling Stone readers think "The Ox" is the greatest bassist of all time means nothing. All it proves is that a lot of people like The Who and have heard time and time again about how great "Thunderfingers" is.

The thing is, he's just not all that great when compared to the players who came after him (who he no doubt influenced). Don't get me wrong, back in 1965 he practically revolutionized bass-playing, and for that he deserves great respect. He's probably inf

···································································

首先，因為《滾石》的讀者認為“公牛”是有史以來最偉大的貝司手，這一切都證明了很多人喜歡“誰”，并一再聽說“霹靂手指”有多偉大。問題是，與他之后的球員相比，他并沒有那么偉大（他毫無疑問是誰別誤會，早在1965年，他幾乎徹底改變了貝司演奏，為此他應該受到極大的尊重。他所受影響的貝司手可能比名單上其他人的總和還要多。然而，與像蓋迪·李或克里夫·伯頓這樣的人相比，他覺得自己已經過時了。是的，他能演奏非常快的五聲力克，而且一般來說，如果有點忙的話，他的低音線比一般的好，但比蓋迪或克里夫好？不，我已經說過，我相信蓋迪是最偉大的，即使他不是我最喜歡的，還有克里夫·伯頓……哇哦，你不能相信的技術加上…更潑辣的男人

The absolute best. Look at the ox bass solo. If anything it should put him at number one for sure.

···································································

約翰“霹靂手指”恩特威斯爾是所有其他貝司演奏者將被比較的基準。他發明了他的雷鳴手指風格并演奏了主低音。恩特威斯爾的風格是獨一無二的，他是一個如此特殊的天才，誰的首席吉他手彼得·湯森是有史以來最好的吉他手之一，鼓勵他把音量調高，因為湯森德希望他的貝司能像他的主唱吉他一樣成為他們歌曲的主要焦點。在YouTube上查看他的視頻。他超越了所有樂隊演奏低音吉他的方式和感知方式。我同意之前的評論，恩特威斯爾很容易就是最好的

People (particularly younger ones, like myself) need to realise that this is not a 'My favorite bassist' list, it's a 'Greatest bassist of all time' list. Burton, Harris, Flea etc are all good bassists, but it was Entwistle's ability to play within the maddest rock quartet in history that made him great; he was a fantastic musician on top of being so technically brilliant. Also, he has influenced every other bassist on this list either directly or indirectly because he was the first (with the ex

···································································

為什么我喜歡Entwhistle：1）基思·穆恩在演奏節奏，湯森也是，他是主角？貝司手約翰·恩特惠斯特是領隊，因為湯森喜歡節奏感。他被稱為公牛是因為2）這在早期作品（我的一代，快樂杰克等）中尤為明顯3）為什么伯頓是1，他真的沒有約翰·保羅·瓊斯那么有天賦，或者這個網站僅僅是一堆Metallica的粉絲（他們甚至不應該是前10名的搖滾樂隊，他們在黑樂隊之后就再也沒有一張好專輯了）是的，我只是浪費了一點時間來貶低Metallica。4）看誰在演唱會上，看看約翰，而不是皮特或基思，看看他的手指！

Rating anything #1 is usually a very hard thing to do, but in this case, it is quite effortless. Also being ranked the best bassist in the world by Rolling Stone Magazine and voted the Bassist of the Millennium, I fail to comprehend how another bassist is seen as better. It is simply impossible. What is truly amazing is that he can play the most amazing solos without seeming to put in any effort. No bassist can replicate him, let alone come up with the solos he came up with. When it comes to she

···································································

當然，喬治列斯被嚴重低估了；畢竟，他是東京酒店的一員，雖然他是一個非常好的樂隊，但在復雜的音樂方面卻非常純樸。這基本上導致了喬治在很多貝司手面前退居二線，因為你不知道他實際上是樂隊中最有才華的成員相對于他的樂器，除非你真的聽了他的演奏。但是他應該是2歲嗎？不可能。我會說前30名，也許。約翰恩特威斯爾在這個名單上太低了，他絕對是我的頭號人物，應該是很多人的

I'm not an expert about musical experts, but I hear a lot of rock music and I think John Entwistle is one of the best bassists I've ever heard, just listen to songs from The Who like "My Generation". I think he deserves more recognition. And I'm starting to be tired of seeing members and songs of Tokio Hotel in the top ten lists about rock. I'm sure Toko Hotel is more popular than talented. Many girls love them because they think they're cute, not because they think they're real musici

···································································

人們（尤其是像我這樣的年輕人）需要意識到這不是“我最喜歡的貝司手”名單，而是“有史以來最偉大的貝司手”名單。伯頓、哈里斯、弗利爾等都是優秀的貝司手，但恩特威斯爾在史上最瘋狂的搖滾四重奏中演奏的能力使他成為偉大的；他是一個很棒的音樂家，而且技術上非常出色，他直接或間接地影響了這個名單上的其他貝司手，因為他是第一個（除了杰默森）真正推動低音和探索可以在搖滾里做什么的人（我知道杰默森不是搖滾，但嘿），他甚至在某些獨奏中放松自己的頭發，在YouTube上搜索它們；有些老家伙可能有點過時了，但他的打球方式（尤其是在我這一代人和其他真正的我身上）已經領先了好幾英里。他是克里夫·伯頓、史蒂夫·哈里斯和比利·希恩，當這些家伙還在尿濕自己的時候（希恩……更厲害）

Clearly those who place John Entwistle so low on this list are still laboring under the delusion that Rush's possesses the best of the best, which is clearly inaccurate. Just listen to "Won't Get Fooled Again. " Amazing chord progression played by the best bassist in the world.

···································································

我不明白約翰·恩特威斯爾怎么能排在第一位。如果這是一個技術熟練的貝司手的排名，約翰輕而易舉地贏了，我真的不認為有人會反對。他也是最有影響力的貝司手之一，他徹底改變了貝司吉他的風格。為普通人敲響大號看他和他的超級組合“最好的”一起表演，在那里他有4分鐘的獨奏。他演奏的是一系列令人困惑的音符和復雜的低音線。他還有很多其他獨奏的好例子。維克多·伍頓應該是第二名，他也許不能像約翰·恩特威斯爾那樣演奏低音，但他肯定是當今世界上技術最熟練的貝司手。斯圖亞特·哈姆也相當令人印象深刻；

This man influenced most of the people on this page. He started from scratch with little people who inspired him and was the first bassist in rock history to write a bass solo. He was also played with THREE fingers. Billy Sheehan, Geezer Butler, Victor Wooten, Kris Novosellic, and TONS of other bassists wouldn't have set their standards so high if it wasn't for him. All I'm saying is if you had any of these bassists came into fame before John than practically everyone would be as slow as a rock