天賜(Heaven Sent)——歐美最佳醫生

天賜(Heaven Sent)——歐美最佳醫生在《歐美最佳醫生》中排名第11名。我們精選了部分網友觀點： ...

天賜歐美最佳醫生在歐美最佳醫生中排名第11名。

·······································································

我們精選了部分網友觀點：

···································································

在我看來，這可能是最感人和扣人心弦的一集，除了《傾聽》之外。只有醫生才能讓它更具影響力，因為你可以聽到這些令人驚嘆的獨白。我認為每一個制作這一集的人都做得很出色，因為它不僅讓人感覺像醫生，而且感覺像莎士比亞。它讓你看到了不同的是，卡帕迪絕對是最好的醫生，這一集讓我更加明白了這一點。當你回放每個去那里的醫生發生的事情時，可能會覺得很無聊，但事實并非如此。當他最終沖破這堵墻時，他所有的努力都得到了回報。你真的覺得自己像你一樣當你在那里的時候，你忘了這是在演戲。感覺太真實了

It is probably one of the most emotional and gripping episodes in my opinion alongside listen. By having only the doctor it makes it so much more impactful, as you get these stunning monologues. I think everyone who made this episode did an amazing job because it doesn't just feel like doctor who, it feels like Shakespeare. It makes you see things differently. Capaldi is definitely the best doctor and this episode just reinforced that for me. The bit where you get the replays of what happened with every doctor who goes there, could have come of as boring but it didn't. When he finally broke through the wall, it was like all his hard work has paid off. You really felt like you were there and you forget that it is acting. It feels so real.

···································································

卡帕迪最精彩的一集，誰知道醫生在鬧鬼的迷宮里自言自語可能會成為這樣一部杰作

Easily Capaldi's best episode, who knew that the Doctor talking to himself in a haunted maze could become such a masterpiece. I still get chills watching it.

···································································

一個簡單非凡的插曲。莫法特用一個復雜的分層腳本來探索醫生真正意義的來龍去脈；它剝去了醫生的外表，展示了醫生處于原始、最純粹的狀態。這一集可能很糟糕，或者只是非常、非常無聊。但是每個參與其中的人都帶來了他們的A-game：史蒂芬·莫法特（Steven Moffat）的精彩劇本，雷切爾·塔拉雷（Rachel Talalay）令人難以置信的有效導演，以及所有演員彼得·卡帕迪（Peter Capaldi）等的令人難以置信的感人表演。我說實話，第9季是我在莫法特時代最不喜歡的系列，但這一集很可能是復興至今最精彩的時刻它會被封頂嗎？不太可能，但幸運的是，一切皆有可能

A simply phenomenal episode. Moffat has really outdone himself with an intricately layered script that explores the ins and outs of what it really means to be the Doctor; it peels back the facade and shows the Doctor in his raw, most pure state.This episode could have easily been bad, or just very, very boring. But everyone involved brought their A-game: a beautiful and brilliant script by Steven Moffat, mind-boggingly effective direction by Rachel Talalay, and an incredibly moving performance by all the actors (Peter Capaldi, Peter Capaldi, etc.).I'll be honest, series 9 is my least favorite series of the Moffat era, but this episode is quite possibly the revival's finest hour yet. Will it ever be topped? Not likely, but with luck, anything' possible.

···································································

《天賜》是有史以來制作的最好的電視作品之一。扣人心弦，有趣，嚇人，還有那破墻的場景！太神了！卡帕迪應該為此獲得很多獎項

Heaven Sent is one of the best pieces of television ever made. Gripping, funny, scary, and that Breaking the Wall scene! Amazing! Capaldi deserves so many awards for this.

···································································

這使卡帕迪成為我最喜歡的醫生。這一切都是由他決定的，不確定其他醫生是否能把它變得如此美麗。你忘了他是個演員。他就是醫生。醫生的這種特殊再生是最強烈、最溫柔、最堅韌的，意志堅強。最不自以為是。這是一個偉大的插曲！讓我成為卡帕迪的粉絲，因為我正在看他的其他電影/節目

This cemented Capaldi as my favorite Doctor. It was all on him and am not sure any of the other doctors could have pulled it off as beautiful. You forget he is an actor. He is the Doctor. And this specific Regeneration of the Doctor is the most intense, tender, tenacious, and strong-willed. And the least self-righteous. Such a great episode! Made me a fan of Capaldi in that I am watching his other movies/shows.

···································································

這一集真是令人驚異的旋風。莫法特在這一集中表現得比他自己強。那蒙太奇可能是52年來《醫生》中最精彩的一幕

What an absolutely stunning whirlwind of an episode. Moffat outdid himself with this one. That montage was probably the best scene of Doctor Who in its 52 years in air.

···································································

這是可怕的，悲傷的，總體上非常美麗和史詩般的，它讓卡帕迪成為我最喜歡的醫生，真是天賜的一集

It's scary, it's sad, and overall very beautiful and epic, and it made Capaldi my favorite Doctor. Truly a heaven sent episode.

···································································

這很容易成為電視界的經典之作，我相信總有一天我會成為有史以來最好的電視節目之一

This could easily become a classic of television. It is masterfully done and I'm sure will make a list of best T.V. of all time someday.

···································································

令人驚訝的是，這一集至少不在前5名，這一集比大多數以上的都要好

Surprised this is not at least in the top 5 this episode is superior to most above it

···································································

史蒂文·克萊死后，決定徹底毀了這一集！而且，沒有真正的惡棍，整個事情只是時間的懦弱的胡說八道

Clara's death was so emotional, and then, after one episode, Steven Moffat decided to completley RUIN IT! Also, there is no real villain, and the whole thing is just timey-wimey nonsense.