暮光歐美有史以來最差的十本書在歐美有史以來最差的十本書中排名第1名。

·······································································

我們精選了部分網友觀點：

···································································

我最初出于好奇嘗試了第一本書。我心想，“嗯，沒關系。它有點俗氣和老土，但它至少是原創的，而且寫作中的細節也相當不錯。”所以我讀了接下來的兩本書。第二本也不錯，盡管在第一、第二和第三本書中，這個角色非常愚蠢過度依賴她的男朋友。在第三本書中……啊。主人公貝拉·斯旺，是一個強大的女主人公的反面。她甚至說她的男朋友對她來說就像毒品，當她關心的每個人都處于危險之中時，她只是坐在角落里看。這本書暗示女人在戀愛中不應該自己做決定，所有的選擇都應該為她們做出。浪漫甚至不甜蜜；她的男朋友過分保護和操縱。很明顯，貝拉在健康課上根本沒注意到，因為他們的關系是虐待關系的定義。事情變得如此糟糕，以至于我……更多

I originally tried the first book out of curiosity. I thought to myself, "Eh, it's okay. It's kind of cheesy and corny, but it's original at least, and the details in the writing are pretty good." So I read the next two books. The second was also okay though in both the first and second (and the third) the character was incredibly stupid and overly dependent on her boyfriend. By the third book...ugh. The main character, Bella Swan, is the opposite of a strong female protagonist. She even says the her boyfriend is like a drug for her, and when everyone she cares about is put in danger, she just sits in the corner watching. The book implies that women shouldn't get to make their own decisions in relationships, all of their choices should be made for them. The romance isn't even sweet; her boyfriend is overprotective and manipulative. Clearly, Bella payed no attention in health class, because their relationship is the definition of an abusive relationship. It was getting so bad, that I ... more

···································································

《暮光之城》系列的第一部我都不知道，但我也不知道有人愛你，就連你們都不討厭。有那么多偉大的人物和故事情節。對你們所有的人來說，為什么還要為一個連讀都沒讀過的人毀了一部連續劇，而且可能也喜歡它。每個人都不一樣，不都在批評一部有缺陷的書，他們都有哈利波特、珀西·杰克遜和饑餓游戲，還有如果有人如此愛另一個人，以至于他們不能沒有他們…那就是真愛。貝拉最后生了一個女兒，愛德華是她的丈夫，她變成了一個強大的吸血鬼，堅強而充滿愛。除非你讀了整本書，否則你不會知道的。每個人都有幸福的結局，現在找到了你的。s M，我覺得你太棒了，繼續夢想，問自己這個問題，你有沒有給這本書一個機會，只是從…更多

I have the whole Twilight series and I love it. For someone who hasn't even read the whole first book you sure seem to know ALL about it. There were weak points in the series but nobody's perfect, not even you haters. There are so many great characters and the story lines great. And for all you haters why even bother ruining a series for someone who hasn't even read it and might love it too. Everyone is different there not all criticising a book series with flaws they all have the even HARRY POTTER, PERCY JACKSON AND HUNGER GAMES, and if somebody loves another so much that they can't live without them... that's true love. Bella ends up with a daughter and Edward her husband and she becomes a powerful vampire who's strong and loving. You wouldn't know that unless you read the whole book series. Everyone gets their happy ending and now find yours.S M, I think your wonderful, keep on dreamingAnd ask yourself this, did you even give the book a chance of just take the word from ... more

···································································

這本書完全是對人類的恥辱。它只關注浪漫的關系。沒有任何刺激或行動情節。寫這本書的作者可能是絕對的白癡和部分愚蠢的，如果她捏造了這樣一個荒謬的想法，那么這篇評論一點也不冒犯。這篇文章是什么廢話。幾乎沒有任何行動或懸念。我完全厭惡，如果我被迫讀它，我會自殺或烤自己。愛德華卡倫根本不是一個稱職的英雄。相比之下，凱撒在《猿類星球》中，《風之兄弟》中的“金鷹亞伯”和《金羅盤》中的伊奧雷克·拜尼森都是更好的榜樣，甚至比他強大得多。去看看克里斯托弗·鮑里尼的《繼承三部曲》、克里斯·D·萊西的《最后的龍編年史》，甚至他的黑暗材料《北極光》就是這部電影以上都是根據。總而言之，這本書完全是弱智。我發誓。我…更-指揮官

This book is an utter disgrace to humanity. Concentrates on nothing but romantic relationships. There is no thrill or action plots at all. The author who must have wrote this (probably) and absolutely idiotic and partially stupid, if she had cooked up such as ludicrous idea (No offense at all for this comment). What utter crap this piece of writing this is. There is virtually no action or suspense whatsoever. I am completely disgusted, and would commit suicide or roast myself if I were forced to read it. Edward Cullen is not at all adequate hero. By contrast, Caesar from the Planet of the Apes, Abel the golden eagle from Brothers of the Wind, and Iorek Byrnison from the Golden Compass are better role models and much stronger than even he is. Go read the Inheritance Trilogy by Christopher Paolini, The Last Dragon Chronicles by Chris D Lacey, or even His Dark Materials ( The Northern Lights was what the film above was based. To conclude, the book is completely retarded. (I swear). I ... more - Command0rSmaug

···································································

我甚至無法描述《暮光之城》中所有的錯誤。首先，是閃閃發光的吸血鬼？說真的，斯蒂芬妮·邁耶？你毀了整個超自然世界。我的意思是，從我記事起，吸血鬼在陽光下燃燒。現在，他們只不過是行走在發光的球體上？不。只是不。第二，別讓我開始演主角貝拉·斯旺。她是個壞榜樣，對她的男朋友太癡迷了。我是說，當他離開她時，她簡直瘋了，為了聽到他的聲音就跳下懸崖差點自殺。Wft？除此之外，她從不做任何有用的事情。我的意思是，在整個系列中，每當遇到任何類型的危險時，她要么擋道，要么奮力拼搏，讓那些試圖保護她安全的人更加難以做到。然而，不知怎的，人們把她列為堅強、女性，像安娜貝絲追逐珀西杰克遜和奧林匹亞，里克里奧丹，克萊爾弗雷凡人…更多

I can't even begin to describe all the things wrong with Twilight. First off, sparkling vampires? Seriously, Stephenie Meyer? You ruined the whole supernatural world. I mean, since as long as I can remember, vampires burned in the sun PERIOD. Now, it turns out that they're just walking glitter balls? NO. JUST NO. Second, don't even get me started on the main character, Bella Swan. She is a bad role model and way too obsessed with her boyfriend. I mean when he leaves her she literally goes crazy and almost kills herself by jumping off a cliff just to hear his voice. Wft? Besides that, she never does anything useful. I mean, throughout the whole series, every time there's any type of danger she just either gets in the way or flings herself at it and makes it way more difficult for the people trying to keep her safe to do so. And yet, somehow people rank her up there with strong, female, heroes like Annabeth Chase (Percy Jackson and the Olympians, Rick Riordan), Clary Fray (The mortal ... more

···································································

我讀過這本書和《新月》，我只打算把這部連續劇看完，因為我想取笑它。太可怕了。我來總結一下Twighlight的整個故事情節，如果你以后想讀這本書的話，你就別讀了：有個叫貝拉·斯旺的女孩去了福克斯，坐在森林里，為自己的生活多么糟糕而郁悶對于愛德華，一個癡迷的吸血鬼來說。對于新月，一開始愛德華離開了貝拉。“我的生命結束了！”貝拉說。然后她嘗試了B計劃：一個有生之年的大塊頭，雅各布·布萊克，后備愛德華。然后愛德華回來，認為貝拉死了。“現在我的生活結束了！”愛德華說，但后來他們重新發現了彼此的愛，在下一本書中還有更多的愛！我在想，“現在我的生活結束了！”是我，還是斯蒂芬妮·邁耶在寫這篇文章的時候編造了Twighlight，在最后的一百頁里，她意識到，“好吧，一定會有某種高潮”，然后包括在內……更多

I've read this book and New Moon, and I'm only going to try to finish the series because I want to make fun of it. It's TERRIBLE. I'll sum up the entire storyline of Twighlight for you (DON'T READ IF YOU WANT TO READ THIS BOOK LATER): there's a girl called Bella Swan who goes to Forks and sits in the forest and mopes about how terrible her life is and for Edward, an obsessive vampire. As for New Moon, at first Edward leaves Bella. "My life is over! " says Bella. Then she tries Plan B: the hunk of a life time, Jacob Black, the backup Edward. Then Edward comes back, and thinks that Bella's dead. 'Now MY life is over! ' says Edward. But then they rediscover their love for each other, and there's more of that to be found in the next book! I'm over here thinking, "Now MY life is over! " Is it just me, or did it seem as if Stephenie Meyer just made up Twighlight as she went along and in the last one hundred pages, she realized, ''well there has to be SOME sort of climax'', and then included ... more

···································································

我剛拿到了四本書，在我讀完饑餓游戲三部曲和幽靈收費站之后，我就開始讀這個系列了。在那之后，我將閱讀所有的《暮光之城》系列，然后去看《發散》。我翻閱了第一本書，說實話，它看起來還不錯。我喜歡斯蒂芬妮·邁耶過去的作品，我希望我會喜歡就像這樣。但是考慮到這個系列的仇恨，我有點不確定一次把四個人都趕出來是不是個好主意。但是我要試試，看看我是否喜歡

I just got all four books and am going to start reading the series after I finish the Hunger Games trilogy and The Phantom Tollbooth. After that, I'm going to read all of the Twilight series and then go to Divergent. I flipped through the first book and honestly it doesn't look too bad. I've liked Stephenie Meyers past works and I hope I'll like this. But considering all the hate this series is getting,I'm a bit unsure if it was a good idea to by all four at once. But I'm going to try it,and see if I like it.

···································································

這本書糟透了！貝拉是有史以來最糟糕的女主角！她是如此的跛腳和可憐，她是自私和可怕的榜樣。這本書沒有任何行動有一個最后的戰斗永遠不會發生…就像這是吸血鬼的書和作家使吸血鬼看起來像一個好人，從不殺人，在陽光下閃閃發光為什么！我永遠不明白為什么這么多女孩愛愛德華。他是一個跟蹤狂，愛上了一個女孩，因為她把一切和每個人都置于危險之中，一周后他開始愛她。邏輯上有人覺得浪漫，但那只是愚蠢和自私。新吸血鬼到底怎么能比老吸血鬼更強大呢別再像哈利·波特系列里的吸血鬼那樣了。別再像《吸血鬼迷宮》里的主角那樣了。別讓他們像《吸血鬼迷宮》里的主人公一樣，去殺吸血鬼了。拜托了，他們應該是《吸血鬼迷宮》里的主角了

This book sucks! Bella is the worst main female character ever! She is so lame and pathetic She is selfish and horrible role model. This book doesn't have any action there is a final battel that never happens...like what this is VAMPIRE book and writer make vampires look like a nice guys which never kill anyone and sparkle in the sun(WHY! ) I will never understand why so many girls love edward. He is a stalker who falls in love with a girl and put everything and everyone in danger because of her ( And he starts loving her after one week...logic) someone finds that romantic but that is just stupid and selfish.And how on earth can new vampires be stronger than older ones. And those main vampires Voluntires (I don't know) are so lame as well.They should be a strong badasses but they can't even fight ( Please Klaus would kill all the vampires in the series in one second) Only strong character in the series is Leah...So people please go and read something normal like Harry Potter,Maze ... more

···································································

我認為人們不喜歡這部連續劇是因為電影，而不是因為這本書。我讀了整個《暮光之城》系列，我不得不說，這是一本構思和情節都很好的好書。角色都很現實，雖然吸血鬼的行為和習慣有點怪異，如果你把注意力放在他們的個性上，你真的可以忽略不計。#任何恨愛麗絲的人都沒有讀過這本書

I think that people dislike this series because of the movie rather than because of the book. I read the entire twilight series and I have to say, it's a good book with good ideas and plots. The characters are realistic and although the vampires' behaviour and habits are a bit weird, you can really overlook it if you focus on their personalities.#Any one that hates Alice hasn't read the book.

···································································

唯一酷的是它是關于吸血鬼和狼人的，沒有別的了。主人公貝拉·斯旺是有史以來最糟糕的女性角色，過于自私和依賴男人。這些書破壞了吸血鬼的形象，愛情故事也很垃圾。我建議你讀一些有意義的書，比如哈利·波特或饑餓游戲相反

The only thing cool is that it's about vampires and werewolves, nothing else. The main protagonist, Bella Swan is the worst female character to ever existed, too selfish and dependent on men. The books ruin the vampires' image and the love story is pretty trashy. I recommend you to read meaningful books like Harry Potter or The Hunger Games instead.

···································································

我記得我第一次接觸《暮光之城》時，我在沙發上看《饑餓游戲》，當時我媽媽正在看《暮光之城》的一部電影。我記得我問過她，“為什么貝拉不像崔絲或卡特尼斯那樣獨立和堅強？為什么愛德華沒有像哈利或珀西那樣的性格缺陷或有趣的故事呢她沒能回答我

I remember the first time I was exposed to Twilight. I was just kinda reading The Hunger Games on the sofa while my mum was watching one of the twilight films. I remember asking her, 'Why isn't Bella independent and strong like Tris or Katniss? Why doesn't Edward have character flaws or interesting stories like Harry or Percy? ' She wasn't able to answer me.