烏馬古馬(Ummagumma)——歐美最佳粉紅弗洛伊德專輯

烏馬古馬(Ummagumma)——歐美最佳粉紅弗洛伊德專輯在《歐美最佳粉紅弗洛伊德專輯》中排名第14名。我們精選了部分網友觀點： ...

烏馬古馬歐美最佳粉紅弗洛伊德專輯在歐美最佳粉紅弗洛伊德專輯中排名第14名。

·······································································

我們精選了部分網友觀點：

···································································

盤是一個很棒的生活與歌曲甚至比原件。盤盤兩個是每個成員做自己的作品。賴特驚人的鋼琴作品,真的展示了自己的才華。沃特斯的歌曲是我最不喜歡的,因為他們是非常安靜和弱。吉爾摩的文章的第一部分是一個溫暖的原聲歌曲沒有歌詞。第二部分是非常迷幻充滿黑暗的迫在眉睫的吉他曲和奇怪的史派西聲音。第三部分可能是最+ u2018normal + u2018專輯的所有歌曲,更直的搖滾歌曲、鋼琴。梅森的文章開始和結束與可愛的長笛,喇叭。中間是一些打鼓漏洞百出的影響。我認為這是一個杰作,值得更多的關注。——SammySpore

Disc one is an AWESOME live disc with songs even BETTER than the originals. Disc two is each of the members doing their own pieces. Wright does an amazing piano piece that really shows off his talents. Waters' songs are probably my least favourite, because they are pretty quiet and weak. Part one of Gilmour's piece is a warm acoustic song with no lyrics. Part two is extremely psychedelic filled with a dark looming guitar riff and weird spacey sounds. Part three is probably the most "normal" of all the songs on the album, being more of a straight up rock song with piano. Mason's piece starts and ends with lovely flutes and horns. In the middle is some drumming with trippy effects. I think this is a masterpiece and deserves more attention. - SammySpore

···································································

我喜歡這張專輯的大部分。那塊不只是活的東西。其實活的東西只有一樣好工作室同行與秘密+ + u2018Saucerful u2018比工作室更值得一聽的版本和與斧尤金+ + u2018Careful u2018很好如果不是有點奇怪。工作室方面確實比生活方面對我來說。我絕對愛+ u2018Grantchester草地+ u2018。這是一個非常美麗的歌,羅格·沃特斯的東西我不知道他有能力寫作。和+ u2018Several種類的毛茸茸的小動物聚集在一個洞里,皮克特人開槽+ u2018涼爽,如果你考慮到都是羅杰水域使這些聲音與他voice.6.3 ++ 10 - Aweso

I actually like a good chunk of this album. And that chunk isn't just the live stuff. Actually the live stuff is only about as good as their studio counterparts with "Saucerful of Secrets" being slightly more listenable than the studio version and "Careful With That Axe Eugene" is good if not a lot a bit weird. The studio side actually does more for me than the live side. I absolutely love "Grantchester Meadows". It's a very beautiful song by Roger Waters (something I didn't know he had the ability to write). And "Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving with a Pict" is cool if you take into account that it was all Roger Waters making those sounds with his voice.6.3/10 - Aweso

···································································

你們這些人就看不到Ummagumma藝術。我認為盤2是更好,因為這是專輯和閥瓣只是一些生活的東西,也是驚人的。在平克·弗洛伊德早期的東西,他們會每隔一段時間有一個歌,不過是附庸風雅的聲音效果,我就是喜歡。這是幾乎所有Ummagumma.Some人說大師草地是唯一真正的歌曲專輯因為它棒和一個連續的即興重復和其他人只是一堆噪音。但是,他們不明白這一切背后的藝術和樂趣。實驗音樂和它應該有這樣的歌曲,每首歌在這張專輯包括Sysaphus、大維齊爾黨,狹窄,甚至幾個小物種大師草地就像一首歌。

You people just don't see the art Ummagumma. I think disc 2 is better because that is the album right there and disc one is just some live stuff (which is amazing as well). In Pink Floyd's early stuff, they would every once and a while have a song that is nothing but arty sound efects and I just love that. This is pretty much all of Ummagumma.Some people say that Grandmaster Meadows is the only real song on the album because it sticks with one continuous riff and the others are just a bunch of noise. But, they Don't see the art and the fun behind it all. It's experimental music and it's supposed to have songs like that. Every song on this album including Sysaphus, The Grand Viziers party, Narrow way, and even Several Small Species are just as much as a song as Grandmaster Meadows.

···································································

這張專輯是如此之低,因為有些人只喜歡verse-refrain歌曲的吉他獨奏之后第二個合唱和一個無聊的即興重復重復整個唱歌。我們不知道有多少不必要的“規則”為寫作音樂。這張專輯有太多自由。——Alkadikce

This album is so low because some people only like verse-refrain songs with a guitar solo after the second chorus and a boring riff repeated through the whole singing. We just don't realise how many unneccessary 'rules' do we set for writing music. This album has so much freedom in it. - Alkadikce

···································································

我明白你的意思但甚至一些前衛的球迷會告訴你這張專輯很無聊的整體,因為它的簡單實驗使它無趣的對許多人來說,在大JoLeKosovo維齊爾的花園聚會。

I see your point but even some avant-garde fans will tell you this album is pretty boring overall, because its simplicity in the experimentation makes it uninteresting for many people, as in The Grand Vizier's Graden Party. - JoLeKosovo

···································································

人人都說盤是驚人的,但從沒有人談到盤兩個好。它是悲傷,因為盤兩個非常被低估。

Everyone says disc one is amazing (and it is), but nobody ever talks about disc two being good. It is sad, because disc two is very underrated.

···································································

唯一的好歌Grantchester草地,活瓣,除此之外,這張專輯很糟糕——MaxPap

The only good song in there is Grantchester Meadows, and the live disc, other than that this album sucks - MaxPap

···································································

無論誰寫的第二個評論,這是可怕的。

Whoever wrote that second comment, that was horrible.

···································································

這是比生活在非洲

This is worse than living in Africa

···································································

起初我以為Ummagumma第二盤不好,但是現在我意識到是多么的偉大,從驚人的鋼琴Sysyphus,平靜的吉他Grantchester草地,毛茸茸的小動物的幾個物種的命運,迷幻的聲音狹窄的方式,平靜的木管樂器大維齊爾的游園會。- SammySpore

At first I thought the second disc of Ummagumma was bad, but now I realize how great it is, from the amazing piano work on Sysyphus, the calming guitar on Grantchester Meadows, the weirdness of Several Species of Small Furry Animals, the psychedelic sounds of The Narrow Way, and the calming woodwinds of The Grand Vizier's Garden Party. - SammySpore